Top, Body, and Upholstery Repair Shops and Paint Shops

SIC 7532

Companies in this industry

Industry report:

Firms in this category repair automotive tops, bodies, and interiors, or engage in automotive painting and refinishing. This includes non-factory customizing of vans, trucks, and automobiles. Firms building custom-designed vehicles on a factory basis are classified in SIC 3716: Motor Homes. Franchise operations are classified under SIC 6794: Franchises, Selling or Leasing.

Industry Snapshot

For almost as long as there have been cars, "scratch and dent" shops have been in business to rejuvenate them. Not long after cars became affordable for most of the public, car owners began looking for ways to "jazz up" their vehicles to suit their individual tastes. Such customizing uses the technology and expertise of the body and paint shop to convert mass-produced cars, vans, and trucks into special-use vehicles.

Although the operations must be physically separated, many body shops also have onsite painting facilities. Generally, these shops strive for a craftsman image, emphasizing quality rather than speed of delivery. Consumers, however, chronically placed auto repair shops in general, and body shops in particular, high on their complaint lists. Franchising, therefore, was an important segment of the industry, combining the small, personal craftsman image with the impact of nationally recognized and trusted trademarks.

According to the U.S. Census Bureau, 34,143 automotive body, paint, and upholstery repair and maintenance shops earned $25.5 billion in revenues in 2010. The industry employed approximately 236,456 people who earned a total annual payroll of $8.7 million. Most firms in the industry remained relatively small, employing fewer than 10 workers, and many of these were owner-operated "mom-and-pop" shops.

Background and Development

In 1937 the price of painting a car ranged between $85 and $350 and took from six days to two weeks to complete. Then the assembly-line paint job was pioneered by Earl Scheib Inc. of California, offering the same job for $19.95 and same-day service with a three-year guarantee. Scheib's technological innovation led to a basic division in the paint and body shop industry that continues to persist in the early 2010s.

Small shops provided detailed precision work using high-grade materials and tools developed for the modern automobile. In the 1980s, the major auto manufacturers switched to unibody construction and metallic paint finishes. Consequently, frame straightening and quality paint application began to require specialized equipment costing hundreds of thousands of dollars. Those shops, which could not afford the massive capital investments in this technologically advanced machinery, became noncompetitive.

In 1987 more than 3,000 converters supplied specialty vans to car dealers and individual buyers. However, the product was often unacceptable to consumers, prompting Ford, General Motors, and Chrysler to establish "consignment pools" of preferred converters. That policy and increasing competition for a dwindling market share drove the number of active converters down to between 300 and 600 by the early 1990s. This number was predicted to decrease even further as larger, better-capitalized conversion firms, such as the Starcraft Corporation, forced out the craft-shops through intense price and service competition. Firms manufacturing for the consignment pool are classified under SIC 3716: Motor Homes.
Assembly lines also provided quality work by specializing in repainting and confining their bodywork services to surface preparation and minor repairs. During the early 1970s, MAACO Enterprises Inc. of Pennsylvania combined the best of both systems with its franchising concept. Instead of creating a chain of company-owned shops, MAACO used its name and national image to tie together a system of 553 independently-operated facilities in 1999. A 1997 issue of Entrepreneur magazine ranked MAACO number one in auto appearance services. MAACO claimed it painted and repaired more vehicles than anyone else in North America. In March 1997, MAACO painted its 10 millionth car in a special promotion commemorating their 25th year in business.

Other firms, like One-Day Paint and Body and Econobake followed. The national clout of these chains and their access to sophisticated tools and training forced many of the marginal craft shops out of business. These franchise operations are covered in SIC 6794: Franchises, Selling, or Licensing.
As the cost of new cars escalated, increasing numbers of Americans were extending the life of their current vehicle with a little paint and body filler. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, automotive repair shops of all kinds took in $65.3 billion in 1997, up from $62 billion in 1996. In 1997 car owners spent $19.8 billion on auto body repair and paint services, nearly one-third of total industry revenues, up from $18.7 billion in 1996.

Increased environmental protection legislation brought additional challenges to paint shops in the 1990s. Paint and body shops were primary sources of air and water pollution and contributed significantly to toxic waste stocks. To address this problem, the industry attempted to reduce and recycle waste thinners, solvents, and paints. The Federal Clean Air Act of 1990 mandated a reduction in volatile organic compounds (VOCs). Consequently, paint shops had to invest in a major retooling of their facilities. The industry warned that it possibly would not be able to meet the new standards, and if it could, prices would soar and quality would plummet. Paint shops were faced with higher handling costs for chemicals, particularly for disposal, in addition to increased retooling and re-education costs. Major assembly plants had been able to reduce their VOC emissions 60 to 90 percent over the decade preceding the Clean Air Act as a result of multi-million dollar investments in ever-changing technology, but small shops lacked the capital to invest in those innovations. In 1990 the switch from oil-based to water-based paints began successfully, but painting processes continued to produce toxic sludge that often ended up in waste dumps. Studies in the early 1990s found that up to 40 percent of sprayed paint was wasted in this manner.

Environmental regulations also made companies legally liable for toxic contamination in waste containment facilities. One of the largest companies in the industry, Earl Scheib, faced two such lawsuits in 1992 for solvents dumped at landfill sites during the 1960s and 1970s. Clean-up costs for these violations reached an estimated $988,000.

Chrysler Corporation began using a method developed by Haden Environmental Corporation of Troy, Michigan, to combat toxic waste produced by auto paint. According to Ward's Auto World, the process recycled the over-spray into a powder, which was then used for under-body paint on Dodge trucks.

Automotive manufacturers introduced water-based paints into their assembly line process with reasonable success in 1982, but these paints required a high-temperature "bake," making them impractical for most aftermarket paint shops. In 1993 Imperial Chemical Industries PLC (ICI) of Britain began preparations to market a new version that eliminated the need for high temperature treatment. The acrylic polymer compound produced an excellent film at 60 degrees Celsius. In England, the new paint commanded a premium of only 5 percent, but in Germany and Italy, it increased the price of a can of paint as much as 30 percent. Some U.S. paint shop operators estimated that the paint and associated equipment could increase their costs between 10 percent and 40 percent, but their main customers, the insurance companies, did not respond quickly to the suggestion of an increase. According to ICI, tests on the process in Germany and Italy found that no major equipment or retraining investments were necessary. Moreover, the system was expected to improve conditions for painters by making the work environment healthier and cleaner. A water-based paint produces 72 percent less VOC emissions than the industry's standard solvent-borne metallic paints, which contain as much as 85 percent solvent. By some estimates, metallic paint spray accounted for one-half of all industrial solvent emissions. Powder coatings emit zero VOCs and were the fastest growing product in the paint and coatings industry.

Acrylic powders were used in the late 1990s in primer surface applications. In 1992 General Motors started using an acrylic-based primer and an acrylic trim coating at its Shreveport, Louisiana, plant then started using acrylic based powder primer surfacer at two other plants. Most producers, however, were aiming to develop clearcoats. In the late 1990s, Ferro, which is one of the world's largest paint suppliers, developed a powder coating that greatly reduced waste and solvent emissions. Its sales grew much faster in North America than in Europe, where powder coatings had been commercialized for a longer period. Most primers and clearcoats were expected to eventually be converted to powder, while the color coats were likely to be converted to waterborne coatings, which retain better color consistency and depth than powder.

In addition to reducing their VOC emissions, auto body shops also had to recycle and capture refrigerants whenever a car's air conditioning system was repaired or scrapped. Before topping up systems, workers were required to check for leaks. Various pieces of equipment, from leak detection gear to recycling/recovery devices were necessary to complete this process. This equipment could cost several thousand dollars when combined.

In 1996 the National Paint and Coating Association announced its coatings CARE Program, which was a progressive initiative that enabled companies to follow a common, effective management approach for their health, safety, and environmental programs. Participation was voluntary, but because the program offered expanded resources, improved communications, and opportunities for heightened industry performance in health, safety, and education, the NPCA believed that participation was vital to an organization's future. They believed that the industry, regardless of size, product, or specialty, would have to adapt to new technologies and respond quickly to keep pace and satisfy growing consumer demands.

Image also became an issue for body shops. Shedding the gritty junkyard image, new shops stressed customer service with clean, friendly environments and easy, main-street access. Some firms used central major repair centers to handle the "heavy-hitters"--vehicles that needed more than $2,500 in body repairs. This practice kept the "wrecks" out of the public eye and improved the body shop's good-neighbor image.

In 2004 the total number of automotive repair shops stood at 61,049, with employment of 252,837 people. Combined industry sales were an estimated $15.5 million. States with the majority of auto repair shops were California, Florida, Pennsylvania, Ohio, New York, and Georgia. Combined, they represented more than 34 percent of the overall market. Automotive body shops represented the largest sector within the industry with 33,855 establishments, or 55 percent of the market. Top, body repair, and paint shops numbered 11,737 and constituted 19.2 percent of the market. There were 3,221 automotive paint shops, 2,880 automotive collision shops, and 2,129 upholstery and trim shops. By 2006 there were 58,215 top and body repair and paint shops, employing 254,774 people and earning $14.87 billion.

Emissions and other "green" regulations continued to proliferate in the environmentally conscious late 2000s. New regulations, effective in 2009 in California, required reduction of VOCs through the substitution of lesser quality water-based coatings for solvent-based. New reduced-solvent coatings began appearing on the market in 2007 to help companies comply with the regulations.

When vehicle leasing was once again a favorable option in the middle of the first decade of the 2000s, it became a promising niche market for auto repair and paint shops. Lessees are required to follow certain guidelines when turning in their lease, so they turn to the auto body shops to fix even small dents or scratches. Auto repair shops that offer "paintless dent repair and detailing services" were more inclined to capture the majority of the market share from leased vehicles.

New car sales dropped drastically as credit dried up and consumers moved to reduce spending during the economic recession at the end of the first decade of the 2000s. The body and paint segment of the auto repair industry was impacted on two fronts. First, business increased overall for repair shops overall, driven by a growing number of people who were choosing to fix their current vehicle rather than trade it in for a new car. The Clarus Research Group reported in June 2009 that 63 percent of U.S. car owners were delaying a new car purchase. However, the same study showed that a majority of Americans were also delaying repairs to save money. Specifically, although consumers were finding their way to repair shops for unavoidable repairs, such as transmission, engine, and brakes work, nonessential repairs, such as dings, dents, and paint work, were being delayed until the economy improved.

Second, with less disposable income available, Americans drove significantly fewer miles at the end of the first decade of the 2000s. As a result, there were fewer auto accidents and fewer insurance claims filed for body work. However, A.M. Best reported that although overall insurance claims were down in 2008 over 2007, the amount per claim increased, with U.S. insurance carriers paying $38.2 billion and $40.2 billion in 2007 and 2008, respectively. The cost increase was attributed to more complicated and high-tech auto configurations.

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) also impacted the industry when it announced new standards in 2009 that required auto paint shops to reduce the toxins released when they strip paint or apply coatings to vehicles. According to the EPA's new rules, paint shops must limit the release of methylene chloride, cadmium, chromium, lead, manganese, and nickel, which are all found in paint stripper, primers, and topcoat pigments. New shops were required to meet the standards immediately, and existing shops had three years to comply. The EPA was particularly encouraging shops to remove paint by dry or wet blasting or using a paint remover that did not contain methylene chloride. Although most dealerships and franchise owners had the necessary advanced equipment to meet the EPA guidelines, small, independent shops had difficulty complying.

Current Conditions

In the early 2010s, the number of body shops at franchised dealerships was declining. According to the National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA), only 33 percent of new-vehicle dealerships had body shops in 2010, down from about 43 percent a decade earlier. Nevertheless, these dealerships generated $6.4 billion in body-shop revenues in 2010, down from a decade peak of about $10 billion in 2004.

According to IBISWorld, this market was saturated and the industry was in the decline stage of its life cycle by 2011. Although more cars on the road might raise the chances of accidents, and thus the demand for body and paint work, IBISWorld also predicted that "consumers will prefer to buy new cars rather than have their older cars repaired." In addition, "manufacturers are introducing safety technologies into new cars"--features that lessened the likelihood of a collision and/or reduced the damage incurred in an accident. Therefore, IBISWorld predicted that value added in this industry would increase only half a percent annually through 2016.

Industry Leaders

In the early 2010s, the paint and body portion of the industry remained highly fragmented, but several well-known companies stood out. Caliber Holdings Corporation of Irvine, California, had 35 shops in California and another 30 in Texas. It also operated a 90,000-square-foot collision repair facility in Santa Monica, California. Sales for the company were $191 million in 2011 with 3,700 employees. Another industry leader was MAACO Franchising, with 500 Collision Repair & Auto Painting shops. In 2008 Driven Brands, owner of Meineke Car Care Centers, purchased MAACO. Earl Scheib Inc. of Sherman Oaks, California, targeted the budget-conscious consumer, and 1-Day Paint and Body Centers Inc. earned half its annual revenue from fleet and wholesale customers.

Workforce

Traditionally, the industry has used a skilled work force trained by apprenticeship. The federal government's Bureau of Apprenticeship and Training worked through state and territorial agencies to promote cooperative programs with employers. Nevertheless, the average body shop employee stayed with an employer for only two years. In 2010, 208,644 people were employed in this industry.

Research and Technology

The technological revolution in paint plants inevitably impacted the small aftermarket paint and body shop. Small shops had to find capital to invest in new materials and costly equipment to remain competitive in the industry.

The "green" revolution was also impacting manufacturer paint facilities. At the Subaru-Isuzu plant in Indiana, for example, managers pushed for a 95 percent reduction in VOCs, rather than the 72 percent expected elsewhere, by combining the use of water-based paint applied electrostatically along with a paint-solvent after-burner. The demand for and popularity of powder coatings increased rapidly due to their zero-VOC content and durability.

Pioneering materials being used by automobile manufacturers also impacted the paint and body shop industry. Automakers, intent on reducing car weight to improve gas mileage, began using more plastic, fiberglass, and aluminum in place of steel. These materials required specialized paint application processes that had to be performed by trained professionals.

New technologies, such as laser wheel-alignment machines, hydraulic frame straighteners, and high-temperature bake ovens, were becoming common at many body shops in order to comply with the consumer demand that the repaired car would look just as good as it did when it rolled off the manufacturer's assembly line. Auto repair and paint shops were also making extensive use of another new tool of the twentieth century--the computer. By 2012 consumers could "upload a photo of their damaged vehicles and receive custom quotes from nearby body shops within 24 hours ... then choose an estimate and book an appointment with the body shop," according to a Manufacturing Close-Up article that described the launch of BodyShopBid in Chicago in 2012.

© COPYRIGHT 2018 The Gale Group, Inc. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan. All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. For permission to reuse this article, contact the Copyright Clearance Center.

News and information about Top, Body, and Upholstery Repair Shops and Paint Shops

New profit center: detail oriented; Detailing can be a lucrative new profit center for your shop--if you do your homework.(body shops management)
Automotive Body Repair News; March 1, 2006; 700+ words
For body shops looking...paintless dent repair and touch...sophisticated paint finishes. Body shops also usually...Successful shops offer value...removal, upholstery or convertible top repair...ft. shop in 1997...has added upholstery and vinyl...
Detail Oriented
Automotive Body Repair News; March 1, 2006; 700+ words
...for your shop-if you...homework. For body shops looking to...paintless dent repair and touch...sophisticated paint finishes...Successful shops offer value...removal, upholstery or convertible top repair...ft. shop in 1997...has added upholstery and ...
One-stop shop gives an edge in heart of Alabama
Automotive Body Repair News; January 1, 2008; 700+ words
...CAPITOL CITY BODY WORKS Capitol...anyone at this shop would be...collision shops in his blood...collision repair shop now employs...comprise an upholstery shop featuring...convertible tops to headliners...of a new paint booth featuring waterborne paints. ...
One-stop shop gives an edge in heart of Alabama.(SHOP PROFILE)
Automotive Body Repair News; January 1, 2008; 700+ words
...Capitol City Body Works (CCBW...anyone at this shop would be...collision shops in his blood...collision repair shop now employs...comprise an upholstery shop featuring...convertible tops to headliners...of a new paint booth featuring waterborne paints. But ...
RK Motors Adds New 40K Sq./Ft. Service and Performance Facility
Entertainment Close-up; September 5, 2012; 609 words
...and service shop in Mooresville...shop, two paint booths...department and upholstery shop. The...complete body, rust and paint repairs, as well...sheet metal repairs and customizations...convertible tops and install...restorations and body ...
United States : Collector Car Leader RK Motors Opens New 40,000 Sq./Ft. Service and Performance Facility
Mena Report; August 31, 2012; 652 words
...and service shop in Mooresville...shop, two paint booths...department and upholstery shop. The...complete body, rust and paint repairs, as well...sheet metal repairs and customizations...convertible tops and install...restorations and body ...
Back from the brink; Lonny Dubay wanted his '64 1/2 convertible restored right, so he did it himself.
Mustang Monthly; June 1, 2008; 700+ words
...Poppy Red paint was faded...convertible top was ripped...Nearly every body panel showed...and the upholstery was literally...collision repair shop in Colorado...learning metal repair, welding...mechanical repairs. By the...including a power top, a Rally...
Former GM factory mechanic has authorities in hot pursuit of his restoration skills.(The Orange County Register)
Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service; June 7, 2000; 700+ words
...little auto-repair shop is literally...because the body style wasn...acceleration or top speed of the...of a small repair shop in San...transmission; new upholstery and paint. The county...the paint and upholstery work, but...

Search all articles about Top, Body, and Upholstery Repair Shops and Paint Shops